
We are beginning to reach the point in the season where aberrations begin to feel a lot more like trends and slumps become struggles, unfortunately for the Braves the offense is still slumping and the pitching is struggling to carry it. And after last night’s long, long loss in San Diego Fredi Gonzalez’s honeymoon period has come to an abrupt and ugly end. Are the issues that anyone holding a bat while wearing a Braves jersey are currently experiencing all Fredi’s fault? No they aren’t but we heard about the more aggressive approach this Braves line-up was going to take, well the aggression is there, every time Dan Uggla flails away at a slider down and away on a two strike count the aggression is there, but for a team that lead the National League in OBP and Base on Balls last year is aggression really a good thing? For some guys like Nate McLouth who struggles to take his walks but was being way too hesitant at the plate last year being aggressive has actually helped him (and remember all things are relative) to post a .244 average and his .190 mark from last year. However when you see Jason Heyward going up and swinging at a fastball up and away on the first pitch it cannot possibly be a good thing. As if to illustrate my point the Braves rank 15th of 16 in teams in the National League in OBP (.296) and 14th of 16 in average (.226) while having the second most at-bats. While watching the sweep of the defending World Champion Giants over the weekend when the Braves drew 16 walks in the 3 games they then conspired to draw no walks in 13 innings. That’s right exactly ZERO walks in three and a half hours of baseball.
The hitting is not what Fredi is catching heat for though, his adventurous (or not) management of the bullpen has drawn criticism from fans using sabermetrics (capitolavenueclub.com) and some applying the good ol’ fashioned eye ball test (talkingchop.com). Whatever the medium of analysis it is being widely accepted that Gonzalez plays Fantasy Baseball and has Craig Kimbrel as his closer and manages his real team to maximise his fantasy success. If only it was that easy to understand what’s going on. One of the fashionable topics being discussed by the talking heads of the statistical baseball world this year has been the management of bullpens and the actual role of a closer; this was further amplified by Ron Washington’s sporadic use of Neftali Feliz in last year’s play-offs. So what opportunities did Gonzalez have to maximise Kimbrels value to the team? The bottom of the 7th inning was his first chance with Maybin on second and two outs Fredi lifted Eric O’Flaherty in favour of righty Scott Linebrink to face Nick Hundley. Linebrink has been struggling and after the game Chipper recognised as much, Liney quickly gave up an RBI double to tie the game. That was his first chance but in the seventh maybe a little early but certainly plausible. Using Jonny Venters in the ninth inning is a reasonable choice but taking him out after only one inning is an absolute joke, let’s remember that Venters had been a starter all his career before the beginning of 2010 so it’s not like he can’t go longer. The brevity of Jonny’s appearance last night is just a footnote to the bumbling bullpen management. After choosing to take Venters out for the ninth why not let Kembo pitch the ninth to ensure you force extra innings, instead Gonzalez went with right-handed Cory Gearrin making his Major League debut to pitch the bottom of the ninth in a tie game. Gearrin was actually really good but who could have predicted that? In fact Gearrin ended up pitching two perfect innings but having Kimbrel pitch those two would have expanded the ‘pen and maybe allowed Gearrin to pitch the 11th and 12th. I am not in any way opposed to using Gearrin in this game, I believe that if you’re having a guy in the bullpen you need to be willing to use him otherwise it is wasting a roster spot so a little credit to Fredi for not being afraid to use him. At the top of the 11th inning Gearrin (who is wearing my spellchecker on his own) was replaced by Christian Martinez which, again, does not upset me too much. Martinez is designated as our long reliever and two of the worst offensive teams in the league were about to begin the 11th inning of a 3-3 game so why not throw Martinez in. Christian’s first two innings were uneventful as he pitched both perfectly using Petco Park to the best of his ability recording five of the six outs on fly balls. Then the circus came to town. The pitchers spot in the line-up came up to bat in the top of the 13th with Nate McLouth on first base, rather than pinch hit David Ross for him and allow Mac to rest Gonzalez allowed Martinez to try and bunt the runner up. Christian bunted into a force out of McLouth at second and nearly had himself doubled off but made it to first in time. The very next hitter Martinez completed his goal to be involved in a double play as he wandered to far from first on a Martin Prado fly out to right field and Chris Denorfia took great pleasure in doubling off the Braves pitcher. This lead to Martinez pitching the bottom of the 13th where he recorded one out before walking Nick Hundley and receiving a visit on the mound. You would have thought this would be a visit to replace him and use Kimbrel or even Jairo Asencio but no, I don’t know whether the visit to see if Martinez was having fun or what he would like for dinner but he stayed in the game to pitch to Ryan Ludwick who quickly deposited the ball over the left field wall.
At my count that’s at least five times that using Kimbrel would have been a better choice that the one the was actually made, unfortunately Kembo got to enjoy an evening reclining in the bullpen seats rather than do anything quite as exerting as his job. If the bullpen is managed like this the rest of the season Kimbrel might not get all that many save opportunities.




